Halcy Research · Health systems

How AI recommends care across US metros

We asked an AI model with web search about care 3,000 times across 30 US metros and 30 service lines, and recorded every local provider each answer recommended. In small metros, the most-recommended health system took a larger share of those recommendations than in the largest metros, and the list often changed when we asked the same question again.

Answers from gpt-5.6-luna through OpenAI’s API with web search, collected ; not the consumer ChatGPT app. The main set asked 10 service lines two ways, three times each, in every metro. A second set asked 20 more lines one way, twice. A local recommendation is one provider an answer recommended inside the metro. Unless a figure says otherwise, it comes from the main set’s “where should I go” answers.

Published , updated .

The leading system

The top system takes more in small metros

For each metro’s most-recommended health system, we measured its share of local recommendations. That share averaged 37.9% across the ten small metros and 23.8% across the ten largest.

All health systems combined received more of the local recommendations in large metros, averaging 80.1% versus 58.4% in small metros, but several systems shared those recommendations. In small metros, the leading system averaged 37.9% of local recommendations, other systems 20.6%, and independent practices and other providers 41.6%.

  • The ten largest metros
  • Mid-size metros
  • Small metros
Average share of local recommendations per metro for the leading system, other health systems, and independent practices and other providers. Each group contains ten metros.
Average share of local recommendations per metro, by market size
MetrosThe most-recommended health systemAll other health systemsIndependent practices and other providers
The ten largest metros23.8%56.2%19.9%
Mid-size metros32.4%23.9%43.7%
Small metros37.9%20.6%41.6%

The leading system’s share remains higher in small metros when we count only links between providers and systems listed in public databases (33.5% versus 21.6% in the largest metros) and across the 20 additional service lines (39.4% versus 31.9%). These recommendation shares do not measure patients or revenue and are not adjusted for how many doctors each system employs.

Individual clinicians

AI names more clinicians in small metros

In where-to-go answers in the ten largest metros, 1.1% of local recommendations named an individual clinician. In the ten small metros, 25.1% did. Small metros were higher in 29 of the 30 service lines. In the 30th, maternity, no where-to-go answer in any metro named a clinician.

By answer, 11 of 300 where-to-go answers in the largest metros named a local clinician, compared with 95 of 300 in small metros. Across the 20 additional service lines, clinicians made up 13.7% of local recommendations in the largest metros and 41.4% in small metros.

Main set · 10 lines

  • Joint replacement1%53%
  • Primary care2%44%
  • Vasectomy8%20%
  • Colonoscopy0%19%
  • Pediatrics0%19%
  • Brain tumor surgery0%7%
  • Psychiatry0%7%
  • Breast cancer0%4%
  • Heart surgery0%2%
  • Maternity0%0%

Second set · 20 lines

  • Plastic surgeon50%76%
  • Physical rehabilitation (PM&R)48%67%
  • Pulmonologist4%58%
  • Rheumatologist20%53%
  • Cataract surgery9%50%
  • ENT2%47%
  • Endocrinologist8%47%
  • Pain management11%43%
  • Sleep medicine20%41%
  • Kidney doctor (nephrology)6%39%
  • Geriatrician17%38%
  • Allergist11%32%
  • Dermatologist4%32%
  • Cardiologist0%32%
  • Hernia surgery4%31%
  • Bariatric surgery0%26%
  • Spine surgery0%26%
  • Child psychiatrist10%22%
  • Vein treatment (vascular surgery)1%16%
  • Neurologist0%16%
Individual clinicians’ share of local recommendations in where-to-go answers, by service line, for the ten largest and ten small metros.
Individual clinicians’ share of local recommendations, by service line and metro size
Service lineTen largest metrosTen small metros
Joint replacement0.7% (1 of 153)53.2% (83 of 156)
Primary care2.3% (4 of 174)44.0% (103 of 234)
Vasectomy8.4% (10 of 119)20.2% (17 of 84)
Colonoscopy0.0% (0 of 136)18.8% (21 of 112)
Pediatrics0.0% (0 of 139)18.7% (28 of 150)
Brain tumor surgery0.0% (0 of 118)7.4% (4 of 54)
Psychiatry0.0% (0 of 126)7.0% (8 of 115)
Breast cancer0.0% (0 of 117)3.7% (2 of 54)
Heart surgery0.0% (0 of 118)2.1% (1 of 48)
Maternity0.0% (0 of 175)0.0% (0 of 56)
Plastic surgeon50.0% (52 of 104)76.0% (57 of 75)
Physical rehabilitation (PM&R)48.4% (78 of 161)66.7% (60 of 90)
Pulmonologist3.9% (3 of 77)58.2% (53 of 91)
Rheumatologist20.0% (22 of 110)53.1% (43 of 81)
Cataract surgery8.8% (8 of 91)50.4% (71 of 141)
ENT2.3% (2 of 86)47.3% (43 of 91)
Endocrinologist8.0% (7 of 87)47.0% (39 of 83)
Pain management11.5% (10 of 87)43.4% (46 of 106)
Sleep medicine20.4% (19 of 93)41.4% (36 of 87)
Kidney doctor (nephrology)6.0% (5 of 84)38.6% (32 of 83)
Geriatrician16.8% (16 of 95)38.5% (30 of 78)
Allergist10.8% (10 of 93)32.3% (21 of 65)
Dermatologist3.8% (3 of 79)32.2% (28 of 87)
Cardiologist0.0% (0 of 80)31.6% (25 of 79)
Hernia surgery4.1% (3 of 73)31.4% (27 of 86)
Bariatric surgery0.0% (0 of 80)26.2% (11 of 42)
Spine surgery0.0% (0 of 85)26.0% (19 of 73)
Child psychiatrist9.7% (7 of 72)22.1% (19 of 86)
Vein treatment (vascular surgery)1.3% (1 of 78)16.4% (10 of 61)
Neurologist0.0% (0 of 76)16.4% (9 of 55)

An individual clinician is a named person, such as a physician or nurse practitioner, rather than a hospital, practice or clinic. This measure describes how answers presented care; it does not measure how many doctors a metro has.

Outside the metro

Small-metro answers reach beyond the metro

In small metros, 14.4% of recommendations pointed outside the metro; 113 of 300 answers included at least one such recommendation. In the ten largest metros, 2 of 1,436 recommendations pointed outside (0.14%).

Most outside recommendations concerned brain tumor surgery, heart surgery and breast cancer. Across the 20 additional service lines, 4.8% of small-metro recommendations pointed outside the metro.

Out-of-market share of affirmative recommendations by market tier
TierRecommendationsOutsideShare, 95% intervalAnswers with one or more
The ten largest metros1,43620.14%0% to 0.34%2 of 3000.67%
Mid-size metros1,3051269.66%5.26% to 14.64%75 of 30025.0%
Small metros1,25918114.38%10.85% to 17.43%113 of 30037.67%

Asking again

Ask again and the list usually changes

We asked each main-set question three times on the same day. In 85% of pairs of answers to the same where-to-go question, the local provider sets differed. We counted close name variants, such as “UCLA Health” and “UCLA Health System,” as one provider.

I need a new primary care doctor in Los Angeles, California. Where should I go?

Answer 1

  1. One Medical
  2. UCLA Health (in all three answers)
  3. Cedars-Sinai (in all three answers)
  4. Keck Medicine of USC
  5. Providence

Answer 2

  1. UCLA Health (in all three answers)
  2. Cedars-Sinai (in all three answers)
  3. Keck Medicine of USC
  4. Providence
  5. LA County DHS

Answer 3

  1. Kaiser Permanente
  2. UCLA Health (in all three answers)
  3. Cedars-Sinai (in all three answers)
  4. One Medical
  5. LA County Health Services
Across three answers about primary care in Los Angeles, UCLA Health and Cedars-Sinai appeared every time. Every other name appeared in one or two answers.
Each square represents one metro and service-line combination. Of 300 combinations, 274 had at least one answer with a different provider set and appear as filled squares. The 26 outlined squares had the same set in all three answers.

Metro and service-line combinations with the same local recommendations in all three answers:

  • Bloomington, IL, Breast cancer
  • Bloomington, IL, Colonoscopy
  • Bloomington, IL, Maternity
  • Charlottesville, VA, Breast cancer
  • Coeur d'Alene, ID, Brain tumor surgery
  • Coeur d'Alene, ID, Maternity
  • Des Moines-West Des Moines, IA, Heart surgery
  • Joplin, MO-KS, Brain tumor surgery
  • Joplin, MO-KS, Vasectomy
  • Kiryas Joel-Poughkeepsie-Newburgh, NY, Brain tumor surgery
  • Kiryas Joel-Poughkeepsie-Newburgh, NY, Breast cancer
  • Kiryas Joel-Poughkeepsie-Newburgh, NY, Heart surgery
  • Lafayette-West Lafayette, IN, Breast cancer
  • Lafayette-West Lafayette, IN, Heart surgery
  • Lafayette-West Lafayette, IN, Vasectomy
  • Modesto, CA, Maternity
  • Ogden, UT, Maternity
  • Omaha, NE-IA, Colonoscopy
  • Philadelphia-Camden-Wilmington, PA-NJ-DE-MD, Breast cancer
  • Portland-South Portland, ME, Heart surgery
  • Portland-South Portland, ME, Maternity
  • Salt Lake City-Murray, UT, Heart surgery
  • Sebastian-Vero Beach-West Vero Corridor, FL, Maternity
  • Sumter, SC, Brain tumor surgery
  • Worcester, MA, Brain tumor surgery
  • Worcester, MA, Maternity

A change can mean one provider was swapped or added. Because all answers came from one day, this measures variation between answers rather than change over time. Across the 20 additional service lines, asked twice, the two answers differed in 89.8% of metro and service-line combinations.

Naming the system

AI usually names the system

Of 1,510 recommendations for doctors and practices belonging to a health system, 90 (6.0%) lacked the system’s name in the answer or any URL cited for them.

Share of system-affiliated recommendations without the system named
  • All system-affiliated recommendations6.0%90 of 1,510

By who was recommended

  • Physicians named individually1.4%3 of 218
  • Group practices6.7%87 of 1,292

By market tier

  • The ten largest metros8.4%52 of 616
  • Mid-size metros6.0%24 of 397
  • Small metros2.8%14 of 497
Run three · no system named
“…worth considering if you live near the Upper East Side, Upper West Side, Midtown, Murray Hill, Tribeca, Long Island City, or Brooklyn Heights. It has numerous dedicated primary-care offices and internal-medicine practices.”

resp_038709449803c345006ac1f72d5fdc87d08b655718b5b7eb05

Run two · system named
“…a strong option if you prefer coordinated care through NewYork-Presbyterian or want locations in Manhattan, Brooklyn, or Queens.”

resp_01e91ba173379f3e006ac1f72d272887d0b5c86a63d8ae25a6

Same practice, two runs. New York, primary care. AHRQ links the Weill Cornell Medicine practice group to NewYork-Presbyterian, and NewYork-Presbyterian’s primary care locations page lists providers from Columbia and Weill Cornell Medicine.

Tracking needs more than one answer

These findings suggest three practices for tracking your system in AI answers.

  1. Compare your system with others in each market, since systems’ shares of recommendations varied with metro size.
  2. Count recommendations of your organization and your doctors. In the largest metros, individual clinicians made up about 1% of local recommendations in where-to-go answers.
  3. Ask each question several times and count how often your system appears. Local provider sets differed in 85% of answer pairs for the same where-to-go question.

By service line

Results for all 30 service lines

The table shows who AI recommended in each of the 30 service lines and compares systems’ share of recommended doctors and practices with their share of local doctors. For the ten main lines, it also shows health systems’ share of all recommendations.

That comparison depends on confirming which doctors and practices belong to systems. Public databases from 2022 and 2023 miss recent hires, so we also checked system websites. Using both sources, systems’ share of recommended doctors and practices exceeded their share of local doctors in 28 of 29 service lines across both sets. With databases alone, it did so in 13 of 23. Both counts include only lines with at least five metros meeting the criteria below. The table shows both versions.

The 30 service lines cover specialties that account for at least 65.4% of active US physicians (674,868 of 1,032,365). Of physicians who belong to a health system and practice in the 30 metros, 65.3% work in those lines’ specialties (85,166 of 130,392).

Results by service line, grouped by role in the study
Service lineWho was recommended locallySystem shareGap vs local supply, all affiliationsGap vs local supply, databases onlySystem not named
Care patients often choose themselves · compared with supply · 52,079 local recommendations · 31.3% hospitals · system share 66.7%, averaged across lines
MaternityTested318 local recommendations94.3% hospitals · 3.5% physicians and groups99.0%308 of 311+30.71 market †–no eligible market10.0%1 of 10
Joint replacementTested475 local recommendations39.4% hospitals · 59.2% physicians and groups68.0%323 of 475+18.927 markets+4.720 markets2.1%3 of 140
ColonoscopyTested360 local recommendations24.2% hospitals · 61.7% physicians and groups · 14.2% other, mostly surgery centers68.9%244 of 354+7.627 markets−6.211 markets4.7%6 of 129
Primary careTested624 local recommendations10.7% hospitals · 89.1% physicians and groups58.1%362 of 623+0.828 markets−7.226 markets6.8%20 of 295
VasectomyTested302 local recommendations3.0% hospitals · 96.7% physicians and groups39.5%118 of 299−10.724 markets−14.115 markets2.7%3 of 110
Specialist care a referral usually decides · descriptive · 3706 local recommendations · 20.8% hospitals · system share 93.1%, averaged across lines
Heart surgeryDescriptive217 local recommendations30.9% hospitals · 68.2% physicians and groups99.1%213 of 215+19.614 markets–no eligible market6.8%10 of 146
Brain tumor surgeryDescriptive244 local recommendations18.9% hospitals · 73.0% physicians and groups · 8.2% ER or urgent care94.2%210 of 223+22.919 markets−43.72 markets9.0%15 of 166
Breast cancerDescriptive245 local recommendations13.9% hospitals · 86.1% physicians and groups86.1%211 of 245+20.627 markets−57.42 markets6.1%11 of 180
Also chosen by patients, outside the comparison · descriptive · 2797 local recommendations · 6.9% hospitals · kept out of the test because Medicare enrollment under-counts independent clinicians in these lines
PsychiatryDescriptive353 local recommendations10.2% hospitals · 63.7% physicians and groups · 26.1% other, mostly ER or urgent care–not in summary+16.925 markets−6.59 markets10.2%13 of 128
PediatricsDescriptive444 local recommendations4.3% hospitals · 75.5% physicians and groups · 20.3% ER or urgent care–not in summary+15.421 markets+13.16 markets3.9%8 of 206
Second set, where-to-go answers only · descriptive · 205,185 local recommendations · 8.6% hospitals · a health system named in 64.8% of all recommendations
Bariatric surgeryDescriptive182 local recommendationshealth system named in 81.6%29.1% hospitals · 70.9% physicians and groups–main set only+19.823 markets ‡too few local specialists in 2 markets−19.83 markets–main set only
Spine surgeryDescriptive239 local recommendationshealth system named in 72.6%25.1% hospitals · 71.5% physicians and groups–main set only+27.425 markets ‡too few local specialists in 1 market+6.710 markets–main set only
Hernia surgeryDescriptive234 local recommendationshealth system named in 75.6%24.4% hospitals · 67.9% physicians and groups · 7.7% other, mostly ER or urgent care–main set only+14.925 markets ‡too few local specialists in 2 markets+3.87 markets–main set only
CardiologistDescriptive228 local recommendationshealth system named in 84.3%15.4% hospitals · 80.7% physicians and groups–main set only+17.428 marketstoo few local specialists in 2 markets−1.99 markets–main set only
Physical rehabilitation (PM&R)Descriptive356 local recommendationshealth system named in 77.3%12.6% hospitals · 86.0% physicians and groups–main set only+30.122 marketstoo few local specialists in 8 markets+25.919 markets–main set only
GeriatricianDescriptive253 local recommendationshealth system named in 78.5%7.5% hospitals · 92.5% physicians and groups–main set only+32.914 marketstoo few local specialists in 16 markets+6.14 markets–main set only
NeurologistDescriptive201 local recommendationshealth system named in 78.7%7.0% hospitals · 88.6% physicians and groups–main set only+15.027 marketstoo few local specialists in 2 markets−8.96 markets–main set only
RheumatologistDescriptive293 local recommendationshealth system named in 74.0%6.8% hospitals · 93.2% physicians and groups–main set only+22.518 marketstoo few local specialists in 12 markets+11.115 markets–main set only
Kidney doctor (nephrology)Descriptive271 local recommendationshealth system named in 69.5%6.6% hospitals · 84.5% physicians and groups · 8.9% ER or urgent care–main set only+15.024 marketstoo few local specialists in 6 markets−1.514 markets–main set only
EndocrinologistDescriptive272 local recommendationshealth system named in 73.3%6.6% hospitals · 93.4% physicians and groups–main set only+17.317 marketstoo few local specialists in 13 markets+0.89 markets–main set only
PulmonologistDescriptive259 local recommendationshealth system named in 83.7%6.2% hospitals · 91.9% physicians and groups–main set only+12.124 marketstoo few local specialists in 6 markets−20.812 markets–main set only
Child psychiatristDescriptive246 local recommendationshealth system named in 55.9%6.1% hospitals · 80.9% physicians and groups · 13.0% other, mostly ER or urgent care–main set only+29.627 markets ‡too few local specialists in 3 markets+20.65 markets–main set only
Plastic surgeonDescriptive298 local recommendationshealth system named in 40.7%5.4% hospitals · 94.3% physicians and groups–main set only+16.417 marketstoo few local specialists in 13 markets+16.713 markets–main set only
ENTDescriptive261 local recommendationshealth system named in 64.8%5.0% hospitals · 91.2% physicians and groups–main set only+19.724 marketstoo few local specialists in 6 markets+0.713 markets–main set only
Cataract surgeryDescriptive340 local recommendationshealth system named in 28.6%4.4% hospitals · 88.8% physicians and groups · 6.8% surgery centers–main set only+11.326 marketstoo few local specialists in 3 markets−3.520 markets–main set only
AllergistDescriptive242 local recommendationshealth system named in 56.2%3.3% hospitals · 96.7% physicians and groups–main set only+39.514 marketstoo few local specialists in 16 markets+23.110 markets–main set only
Sleep medicineDescriptive278 local recommendationshealth system named in 70.2%3.2% hospitals · 96.8% physicians and groups–main set only+33.310 marketstoo few local specialists in 20 markets+15.74 markets–main set only
Pain managementDescriptive282 local recommendationshealth system named in 56.1%2.5% hospitals · 95.7% physicians and groups–main set only+48.215 marketstoo few local specialists in 15 markets+20.39 markets–main set only
DermatologistDescriptive251 local recommendationshealth system named in 37.5%2.0% hospitals · 97.6% physicians and groups–main set only+24.723 marketstoo few local specialists in 7 markets+14.615 markets–main set only
Vein treatment (vascular surgery)Descriptive199 local recommendationshealth system named in 58.7%1.5% hospitals · 98.5% physicians and groups–main set only+6.217 marketstoo few local specialists in 13 markets−8.16 markets–main set only

Who was recommended counts local recommendations in where-to-go answers, combining three answers per metro in the main set and two in the second.

System share is the percentage of recommendations that went to health systems, among providers whose system or independent status we could confirm.

Gap vs local supply subtracts systems’ share of local doctors in the relevant specialties from their share of recommended doctors and practices. A positive gap, in percentage points, means the recommendation share was larger. Each line averages metros with at least 10 local doctors in its specialties and at least 3 recommended doctors or practices with confirmed system or independent status. Databases only shows the same gap without website checks. Bars stop at ±35 points; the printed value is the full gap.

Too few local specialists counts metros left out of a second-set line’s gaps because they had fewer than 10 local doctors in its specialties. In small metros, that ruled out 118 of 200 metro and service-line combinations.

System not named counts recommendations for system-affiliated doctors and practices where neither the answer nor any URL cited for them named the system.

Health system named, second set only, is the share of all its recommendations, local or not, where the answer or a cited URL named a health system.

† One qualifying metro, Philadelphia.

‡ Local doctors counted from a broader specialty: general surgery for hernia and bariatric surgery, orthopedic surgery and neurosurgery for spine surgery, and all of psychiatry for child psychiatry.

Cited sources

The sources AI cited when recommending doctors

We asked for the best doctor in 10 specialties, in 30 U.S. metros, three times each: 900 answers, 90 per specialty. For each specialty, the map shows how many of those answers cited each website at least once.

Primary care, as askedWho is the best primary care doctor in [city]?

“Who is the best doctor?” answers: percent of 90 answers citing each source, by specialty. The column headings select a specialty.
Cited in 5 or more specialties
Healthgradeshealthgrades.comHealthgrades, Brain surgery: 4%, 4 of 90 answers from 4 of 30 metrosHealthgrades, Breast cancer: 6%, 5 of 90 answers from 3 of 30 metrosHealthgrades, Colonoscopy: 21%, 19 of 90 answers from 11 of 30 metrosHealthgrades, Heart surgery: 7%, 6 of 90 answers from 3 of 30 metrosHealthgrades, Knee replacement: 1%, 1 of 90 answers from 1 of 30 metrosHealthgrades, OB-GYN: 26%, 23 of 90 answers from 13 of 30 metrosHealthgrades, Pediatrics: 21%, 19 of 90 answers from 12 of 30 metrosHealthgrades, Primary care: 37%, 33 of 90 answers from 20 of 30 metrosHealthgrades, Psychiatry: 28%, 25 of 90 answers from 15 of 30 metrosHealthgrades, Vasectomy: 14%, 13 of 90 answers from 9 of 30 metros
WebMD doctor directorydoctor.webmd.comWebMD doctor directory, Brain surgery: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosWebMD doctor directory, Breast cancer: 3%, 3 of 90 answers from 2 of 30 metrosWebMD doctor directory, Colonoscopy: 11%, 10 of 90 answers from 5 of 30 metrosWebMD doctor directory, Heart surgery: 1%, 1 of 90 answers from 1 of 30 metrosWebMD doctor directory, Knee replacement: 1%, 1 of 90 answers from 1 of 30 metrosWebMD doctor directory, OB-GYN: 9%, 8 of 90 answers from 5 of 30 metrosWebMD doctor directory, Pediatrics: 8%, 7 of 90 answers from 6 of 30 metrosWebMD doctor directory, Primary care: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosWebMD doctor directory, Psychiatry: 6%, 5 of 90 answers from 5 of 30 metrosWebMD doctor directory, Vasectomy: 6%, 5 of 90 answers from 4 of 30 metros
ThreeBestRatedthreebestrated.comThreeBestRated, Brain surgery: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosThreeBestRated, Breast cancer: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosThreeBestRated, Colonoscopy: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosThreeBestRated, Heart surgery: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosThreeBestRated, Knee replacement: 2%, 2 of 90 answers from 1 of 30 metrosThreeBestRated, OB-GYN: 3%, 3 of 90 answers from 2 of 30 metrosThreeBestRated, Pediatrics: 12%, 11 of 90 answers from 7 of 30 metrosThreeBestRated, Primary care: 2%, 2 of 90 answers from 2 of 30 metrosThreeBestRated, Psychiatry: 3%, 3 of 90 answers from 3 of 30 metrosThreeBestRated, Vasectomy: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metros
Cited in fewer specialties
National Cancer Institutecancer.govNational Cancer Institute, Brain surgery: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosNational Cancer Institute, Breast cancer: 11%, 10 of 90 answers from 8 of 30 metrosNational Cancer Institute, Colonoscopy: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosNational Cancer Institute, Heart surgery: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosNational Cancer Institute, Knee replacement: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosNational Cancer Institute, OB-GYN: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosNational Cancer Institute, Pediatrics: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosNational Cancer Institute, Primary care: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosNational Cancer Institute, Psychiatry: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosNational Cancer Institute, Vasectomy: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metros
NCI cancer center directorycancercenters.cancer.govNCI cancer center directory, Brain surgery: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosNCI cancer center directory, Breast cancer: 11%, 10 of 90 answers from 5 of 30 metrosNCI cancer center directory, Colonoscopy: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosNCI cancer center directory, Heart surgery: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosNCI cancer center directory, Knee replacement: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosNCI cancer center directory, OB-GYN: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosNCI cancer center directory, Pediatrics: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosNCI cancer center directory, Primary care: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosNCI cancer center directory, Psychiatry: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosNCI cancer center directory, Vasectomy: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metros
STS Public Reportingpublicreporting.sts.orgSTS Public Reporting, Brain surgery: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosSTS Public Reporting, Breast cancer: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosSTS Public Reporting, Colonoscopy: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosSTS Public Reporting, Heart surgery: 12%, 11 of 90 answers from 8 of 30 metrosSTS Public Reporting, Knee replacement: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosSTS Public Reporting, OB-GYN: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosSTS Public Reporting, Pediatrics: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosSTS Public Reporting, Primary care: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosSTS Public Reporting, Psychiatry: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosSTS Public Reporting, Vasectomy: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metros
Birdeye reviewsreviews.birdeye.comBirdeye reviews, Brain surgery: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosBirdeye reviews, Breast cancer: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosBirdeye reviews, Colonoscopy: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosBirdeye reviews, Heart surgery: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosBirdeye reviews, Knee replacement: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosBirdeye reviews, OB-GYN: 2%, 2 of 90 answers from 2 of 30 metrosBirdeye reviews, Pediatrics: 13%, 12 of 90 answers from 8 of 30 metrosBirdeye reviews, Primary care: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosBirdeye reviews, Psychiatry: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosBirdeye reviews, Vasectomy: 8%, 7 of 90 answers from 7 of 30 metros
Psychology Todaypsychologytoday.comPsychology Today, Brain surgery: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosPsychology Today, Breast cancer: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosPsychology Today, Colonoscopy: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosPsychology Today, Heart surgery: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosPsychology Today, Knee replacement: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosPsychology Today, OB-GYN: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosPsychology Today, Pediatrics: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosPsychology Today, Primary care: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosPsychology Today, Psychiatry: 24%, 22 of 90 answers from 13 of 30 metrosPsychology Today, Vasectomy: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metros
American Urological Assn.auanet.orgAmerican Urological Assn., Brain surgery: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosAmerican Urological Assn., Breast cancer: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosAmerican Urological Assn., Colonoscopy: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosAmerican Urological Assn., Heart surgery: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosAmerican Urological Assn., Knee replacement: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosAmerican Urological Assn., OB-GYN: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosAmerican Urological Assn., Pediatrics: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosAmerican Urological Assn., Primary care: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosAmerican Urological Assn., Psychiatry: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosAmerican Urological Assn., Vasectomy: 20%, 18 of 90 answers from 12 of 30 metros
Planned Parenthoodplannedparenthood.orgPlanned Parenthood, Brain surgery: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosPlanned Parenthood, Breast cancer: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosPlanned Parenthood, Colonoscopy: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosPlanned Parenthood, Heart surgery: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosPlanned Parenthood, Knee replacement: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosPlanned Parenthood, OB-GYN: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosPlanned Parenthood, Pediatrics: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosPlanned Parenthood, Primary care: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosPlanned Parenthood, Psychiatry: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosPlanned Parenthood, Vasectomy: 13%, 12 of 90 answers from 6 of 30 metros

Primary care, as askedWho is the best primary care doctor in [city]?

Primary care: percent of 90 answers citing each source
Primary care% of 90
HealthgradesHealthgrades, Primary care: 37%, 33 of 90 answers from 20 of 30 metros
WebMD doctor directoryWebMD doctor directory, Primary care: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metros
ThreeBestRatedThreeBestRated, Primary care: 2%, 2 of 90 answers from 2 of 30 metros
National Cancer InstituteNational Cancer Institute, Primary care: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metros
NCI cancer center directoryNCI cancer center directory, Primary care: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metros
STS Public ReportingSTS Public Reporting, Primary care: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metros
Birdeye reviewsBirdeye reviews, Primary care: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metros
Psychology TodayPsychology Today, Primary care: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metros
American Urological Assn.American Urological Assn., Primary care: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metros
Planned ParenthoodPlanned Parenthood, Primary care: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metros

How to read this. A cell is the share of 90 answers (30 metros, each asked three times) that cited the source anywhere in the answer, rounded: 37 means 33 of 90. The map shows every source cited in at least 10 answers from at least 5 metros in any one specialty, with all of its cells, zeros included. Repeats in one metro are not separate markets, so the exact counts below sit beside the number of metros. A citation can support general guidance rather than a particular doctor.

Showing Primary care

Primary care: what the answers cited

The 90 answers cited 114 different websites. These are the mapped sources among them.

SourceAnswers citing it, of 90Cited pages
Healthgradeshealthgrades.com21 directory lists, 12 clinician profilesRequest changes from the owner
37%33 of 90 answers · 20 of 30 metros
ThreeBestRatedthreebestrated.com2 directory listsRequest changes from the owner
2%2 of 90 answers · 2 of 30 metros

Not cited for primary care (0 of 90): WebMD doctor directory, National Cancer Institute, NCI cancer center directory, STS Public Reporting, Birdeye reviews, Psychology Today, American Urological Assn, Planned Parenthood.

Source guide

What the cited pages are, and what a health system can do

We opened the pages these answers cited for each of the 10 sources, or a sample where a site blocked automated loading, and recorded what each page is, who maintains its information and, where the owner publishes one, how to update it. Accurate profiles and a clear way to request an appointment are changes a health system can make and then measure. This study did not test whether they change recommendations or appointment requests.

Listings and records another organization maintains

The owner publishes them, often from data a health system or its clinicians supply, so changes are requested from the owner. Where the owner publishes a way to claim, update or review an entry, the guide links it; where it does not, the guide says so.

Healthgradeshealthgrades.comDirectory lists, Clinician profiles, Facility profiles148answers · 134 pages

Operated by Healthgrades Marketplace, LLC, an RVO Health company.

Directory lists · 73 directory lists cited · request changes from the owner
Maintained by
Healthgrades generates these lists from its own provider profiles; its help center says that data comes from the NPI Registry, patient surveys, government and third-party claims data, and information supplied by professionals or practices.
What a health system can do
The Healthgrades help center says an authorized representative for more than one provider can see a roster of those providers, open each profile for editing, and manage their patient reviews. Owner’s page, checked November 15, 2026.

Healthgrades decides which clinicians a list shows and in what order; claiming changes the profiles behind a list, not the list. Of the 74 lists either question cited, 26 carried listings labeled sponsored, which Healthgrades says hospitals and medical groups can buy.

Clinician profiles · 60 clinician profiles cited · request changes from the owner
Maintained by
Healthgrades builds each profile from government and commercial data sources and patient surveys; a clinician or an authorized representative who claims the free profile can edit it, and the help center says Healthgrades does not overwrite information a practice keeps current.
What a health system can do
The Healthgrades for Professionals claim page invites a clinician to find and claim a free profile, asks for a DEA or state license number for verification, and states that only physicians or their authorized representatives may manage a physician's profile. Owner’s page, checked November 15, 2026.

Each cited profile showed a 'Last verified' date and a claim prompt. Healthgrades says profile edits also appear on its partner sites, and that anyone can report incorrect profile information through a form.

Facility profiles · 1 facility profile cited · request changes from the owner
Maintained by
The group practice page draws on Healthgrades' provider data, and authorized representatives can edit practice and office locations.
What a health system can do
The help center says an authorized representative for more than one provider can add, edit and remove practices and office locations and choose which providers are associated with each location. Owner’s page, checked November 15, 2026.

The route covers the practice's details and office locations.

WebMD doctor directorydoctor.webmd.comDirectory lists, Clinician profiles40answers · 35 pages

Operated by WebMD LLC, an Internet Brands company.

Directory lists · 14 directory lists cited · request changes from the owner
Maintained by
WebMD Care generates these lists from its provider profiles, which the profile pages say are sourced from the physicians themselves and publicly available databases.
What a health system can do
The WebMD Care Directories page offers a form to access a free Basic Profile and describes paid Featured Profiles, which it says are pinned to the top of search results for local physicians in the same field. Owner’s page, checked November 15, 2026.

11 of the 14 cited lists showed a 'Featured Results' block, which WebMD describes as paid placement. Claiming changes individual listings, not the order WebMD gives them.

Clinician profiles · 21 clinician profiles cited · request changes from the owner
Maintained by
WebMD Care publishes the profiles; the pages say the data comes from physicians and publicly available databases, that a provider who claims and verifies the profile can update it, and that reviews come from users.
What a health system can do
The profile claim form says registering grants access to update the listing on all sites in WebMD's directory network and that only physicians and practices can update their listings. Owner’s page, checked November 15, 2026.

18 of the 21 cited profiles showed a 'Claim your profile' link; whether the other three are already claimed is not established.

Not established: WebMD's claim forms say only physicians and practices can update listings; we found no route for a health system's central office. Whether three cited clinician profiles without a claim link are already claimed.

Psychology Todaypsychologytoday.comDirectory lists, Clinician profiles, Facility profiles22answers · 26 pages

Operated by Sussex Directories Inc..

Directory lists · 10 directory lists cited · request changes from the owner
Maintained by
Psychology Today assembles the list from member profiles; the terms say every listed professional pays a subscription fee and is responsible for keeping its own profile accurate.
What a health system can do
Psychology Today's Join page invites professionals to create a profile that appears in the directory and states a fixed membership fee of $29.95 a month with no contract; it does not describe how to correct an existing profile. Owner’s page, checked November 15, 2026.

A health system's clinicians appear on these lists only if each holds its own paid profile; the terms say every member pays the same fee.

Clinician profiles · 15 clinician profiles cited · request changes from the owner
Maintained by
The listed professional writes and pays for the profile; the terms say profile content is self-reported and/or gathered from verified third-party sources, that each member is responsible for its accuracy, and that Sussex Directories does not control, verify or take responsibility for member content.
What a health system can do
Psychology Today's Join page invites professionals to create a profile that appears in the directory and states a fixed membership fee of $29.95 a month with no contract; it does not describe how to correct an existing profile. Owner’s page, checked November 15, 2026.

The terms make each member responsible for its profile's accuracy and send concerns about a listed professional to Psychology Today's support email.

Facility profiles · 1 facility profile cited · request changes from the owner
Maintained by
The practice writes and pays for the profile as a Psychology Today member.
What a health system can do
Psychology Today's Join page invites professionals to create a profile that appears in the directory and states a fixed membership fee of $29.95 a month with no contract; it does not describe how to correct an existing profile. Owner’s page, checked November 15, 2026.

This practice-named profile uses the same format as individual clinicians' profiles.

Not established: The site blocked automated loading, so 8 of the 34 pages either question cited were opened and the rest classified from their addresses. Psychology Today publishes no route for a third party, such as a health system, to correct a clinician's profile beyond a support email and a 'Report an issue' link. How the site's terms, which bar promoting group practices, apply to profiles named for a practice rather than a clinician.

Birdeye reviewsreviews.birdeye.comDirectory lists, Clinician profiles, Facility profiles21answers · 18 pages

Operated by BirdEye, Inc..

Directory lists · 2 directory lists cited · request changes from the owner
Maintained by
Birdeye generates the list from its own business profiles; the page offers an 'Add business' option for businesses not shown.
What a health system can do
Birdeye's claim page for a cited profile says the business can claim its free profile by email or Google sign-in, confirm its name, email and phone, then add photos, hours, services and links and collect and respond to reviews. Owner’s page, checked November 15, 2026.

Birdeye decides which businesses a list shows and in what order; claiming changes the profiles behind a list.

Clinician profiles · 7 clinician profiles cited · request changes from the owner
Maintained by
Birdeye publishes these profiles before any business involvement; every cited profile stated it had not been claimed by the business owner or representative, and the ratings shown draw on reviews from other sites.
What a health system can do
Birdeye's claim page for a cited profile says the business can claim its free profile by email or Google sign-in, confirm its name, email and phone, then add photos, hours, services and links and collect and respond to reviews. Owner’s page, checked November 15, 2026.

Every cited profile said it had not been claimed. Each has its own claim link and a 'Suggest edits' link.

Facility profiles · 9 facility profiles cited · request changes from the owner
Maintained by
Birdeye publishes these practice profiles before any business involvement; every cited profile stated it had not been claimed, and the ratings shown draw on reviews from other sites.
What a health system can do
Birdeye's claim page for a cited profile says the business can claim its free profile by email or Google sign-in, confirm its name, email and phone, then add photos, hours, services and links and collect and respond to reviews. Owner’s page, checked November 15, 2026.

Every cited profile said it had not been claimed, and 15 of the 16 cited Birdeye profiles showed no reviews written on Birdeye itself; their ratings come from sites such as Facebook, Healthgrades and Yellow Pages.

Not established: Which outside review sites make up each profile's totals.

ThreeBestRatedthreebestrated.comDirectory lists21answers · 15 pages

Operated by Signature Profit LLC.

Directory lists · 15 directory lists cited · request changes from the owner
Maintained by
ThreeBestRated's team selects the three businesses and publishes the entries; its About page says every business is checked manually through a '50-Point Inspection' and that businesses cannot pay to be featured.
What a health system can do
The Update Business page says a listed business can email support@threebestrated.com for small changes or submit a free form for its address, phone, hours, services and other details, which the team reviews manually, taking up to 3 business days, before publishing. Owner’s page, checked November 15, 2026.

Each cited page names exactly three businesses for one specialty and city. A listed business can update its entry; the site decides who is listed.

STS Public Reportingpublicreporting.sts.orgQuality records11answers · 8 pages

Operated by The Society of Thoracic Surgeons (STS).

Quality records · 8 quality records cited · request changes from the owner
Maintained by
STS calculates and publishes the scores and star ratings from surgical case data that participants (most often a hospital cardiothoracic surgery department or surgical group, occasionally an individual surgeon) submit to the STS National Database.
What a health system can do
STS's FAQ says public reporting is completely voluntary for database participants, who enroll by sending a completed consent form to publicreporting@sts.org and may unenroll at any time. Owner’s page, checked November 15, 2026.

A program appears only if it participates in the STS National Database and consents to publication. STS says results reflect each participant's case mix and are not meant for direct comparison. It publishes no process for disputing a published score.

Not established: STS publishes no process for disputing a published rating.

National Cancer Institutecancer.govFacility profiles, Directory lists10answers · 8 pages

Operated by National Cancer Institute (NCI).

Facility profiles · 7 facility profiles cited · request changes from the owner
Maintained by
NCI hosts the profiles, and of the 16 profiles either question cited, 15 state that the profile information was provided by the cancer center itself; the MD Anderson profile carries no such note.
What a health system can do
Request changes from the owner. The owner publishes no route for this.

A center has a profile once it holds NCI designation. Of the 16 profiles either question cited, 15 say the center supplied the text; NCI publishes no process for changing it.

Directory lists · 1 directory list cited · request changes from the owner
Maintained by
NCI.
What a health system can do
Request changes from the owner. The owner publishes no route for this.

Lists only NCI-designated centers; designation comes with NCI's P30 Cancer Center Support Grant.

Not established: NCI publishes no process for a designated center to update its cancer.gov profile.

NCI cancer center directorycancercenters.cancer.govFacility profiles, Directory lists10answers · 5 pages

Operated by National Cancer Institute, Office of Cancer Centers.

Facility profiles · 4 facility profiles cited · request changes from the owner
Maintained by
NCI's Office of Cancer Centers publishes a profile for each NCI-designated center and dates each one; these pages do not say who supplies the text.
What a health system can do
Request changes from the owner. The owner publishes no route for this.

A center is listed once it holds NCI designation, which NCI's Office of Cancer Centers says comes with its P30 Cancer Center Support Grant. NCI publishes no process for updating a profile; its contact page lists a phone number and an email address. A profile describes the designated center, which can differ from the hospital or breast program an answer named.

Directory lists · 1 directory list cited · request changes from the owner
Maintained by
NCI's Office of Cancer Centers compiles this list of NCI-designated centers.
What a health system can do
Request changes from the owner. The owner publishes no route for this.

Only NCI-designated centers appear, 74 when checked. Designation, which comes with NCI's P30 Cancer Center Support Grant, is what puts a center on the list.

Not established: NCI publishes no process for a designated center to update its directory profile. Who writes these profiles; the cancer.gov profiles for the same centers say the center supplied the text.

Pages another provider publishes itself

Only that provider can change them.

Planned Parenthoodplannedparenthood.orgProvider service pages12answers · 7 pages

Operated by Planned Parenthood Federation of America, with pages run by its separately incorporated affiliates.

Provider service pages · 7 provider service pages cited · published by that provider
Maintained by
The Planned Parenthood affiliate named on each page; affiliate pages carry that affiliate's copyright line, and health center pages say "Operated by" the affiliate.
What a health system can do
Published by that provider.

Health center and affiliate pages, each run by a separately incorporated Planned Parenthood affiliate; only that affiliate can change them. Of the 16 health center pages either question cited, ten did not mention vasectomy when checked.

General reference

Patient education and clinical guidance with no ordinary way for a health system to add its own information.

American Urological Assn.auanet.orgPatient education18answers · 5 pages

Operated by American Urological Association (AUA).

Patient education · 5 patient education pages cited · reference only
Maintained by
The AUA; the guideline was written by an AUA expert panel, and the documents carry AUA copyright (the Journal of Urology reprint names American Urological Association Education and Research, Inc.).
What a health system can do
Reference only.

All five cited pages are AUA's 2012 vasectomy guideline for clinicians, one in its journal version. AUA now files it as archived; its 2026 guideline requires a member login.

Not established: Whether AUA's member directory is public; it requires a member login.

Secondary analysisThe same specialties, asked “Where should I go?”Each specialty was also asked a second way, such as “I need a new primary care doctor in [city]. Where should I go?” Compare both wordings across 1,800 answers and the 15 sources either one cited often.
Question wording shown in the map
A, “Where should I go?” wording: percent of 90 answers citing each source, by service line. The column headings select a service line.
Cited in 5 or more service lines, either wording
Healthgradeshealthgrades.comHealthgrades, Brain tumor surgery, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosHealthgrades, Breast cancer, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosHealthgrades, Colonoscopy, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosHealthgrades, Heart surgery, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosHealthgrades, Joint replacement, A: 3%, 3 of 90 answers from 2 of 30 metrosHealthgrades, Maternity, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosHealthgrades, Pediatrics, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosHealthgrades, Primary care, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosHealthgrades, Psychiatry, A: 1%, 1 of 90 answers from 1 of 30 metrosHealthgrades, Vasectomy, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metros
Mayo Clinicmayoclinic.orgMayo Clinic, Brain tumor surgery, A: 12%, 11 of 90 answers from 9 of 30 metrosMayo Clinic, Breast cancer, A: 3%, 3 of 90 answers from 1 of 30 metrosMayo Clinic, Colonoscopy, A: 7%, 6 of 90 answers from 3 of 30 metrosMayo Clinic, Heart surgery, A: 7%, 6 of 90 answers from 4 of 30 metrosMayo Clinic, Joint replacement, A: 3%, 3 of 90 answers from 1 of 30 metrosMayo Clinic, Maternity, A: 2%, 2 of 90 answers from 1 of 30 metrosMayo Clinic, Pediatrics, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosMayo Clinic, Primary care, A: 3%, 3 of 90 answers from 1 of 30 metrosMayo Clinic, Psychiatry, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosMayo Clinic, Vasectomy, A: 6%, 5 of 90 answers from 4 of 30 metros
WebMD doctor directorydoctor.webmd.comWebMD doctor directory, Brain tumor surgery, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosWebMD doctor directory, Breast cancer, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosWebMD doctor directory, Colonoscopy, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosWebMD doctor directory, Heart surgery, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosWebMD doctor directory, Joint replacement, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosWebMD doctor directory, Maternity, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosWebMD doctor directory, Pediatrics, A: 1%, 1 of 90 answers from 1 of 30 metrosWebMD doctor directory, Primary care, A: 1%, 1 of 90 answers from 1 of 30 metrosWebMD doctor directory, Psychiatry, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosWebMD doctor directory, Vasectomy, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metros
ThreeBestRatedthreebestrated.comThreeBestRated, Brain tumor surgery, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosThreeBestRated, Breast cancer, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosThreeBestRated, Colonoscopy, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosThreeBestRated, Heart surgery, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosThreeBestRated, Joint replacement, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosThreeBestRated, Maternity, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosThreeBestRated, Pediatrics, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosThreeBestRated, Primary care, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosThreeBestRated, Psychiatry, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosThreeBestRated, Vasectomy, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metros
Cited in fewer service lines
National Cancer Institutecancer.govNational Cancer Institute, Brain tumor surgery, A: 17%, 15 of 90 answers from 12 of 30 metrosNational Cancer Institute, Breast cancer, A: 57%, 51 of 90 answers from 26 of 30 metrosNational Cancer Institute, Colonoscopy, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosNational Cancer Institute, Heart surgery, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosNational Cancer Institute, Joint replacement, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosNational Cancer Institute, Maternity, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosNational Cancer Institute, Pediatrics, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosNational Cancer Institute, Primary care, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosNational Cancer Institute, Psychiatry, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosNational Cancer Institute, Vasectomy, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metros
NCI cancer center directorycancercenters.cancer.govNCI cancer center directory, Brain tumor surgery, A: 2%, 2 of 90 answers from 1 of 30 metrosNCI cancer center directory, Breast cancer, A: 12%, 11 of 90 answers from 8 of 30 metrosNCI cancer center directory, Colonoscopy, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosNCI cancer center directory, Heart surgery, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosNCI cancer center directory, Joint replacement, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosNCI cancer center directory, Maternity, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosNCI cancer center directory, Pediatrics, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosNCI cancer center directory, Primary care, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosNCI cancer center directory, Psychiatry, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosNCI cancer center directory, Vasectomy, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metros
American Heart Associationheart.orgAmerican Heart Association, Brain tumor surgery, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosAmerican Heart Association, Breast cancer, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosAmerican Heart Association, Colonoscopy, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosAmerican Heart Association, Heart surgery, A: 30%, 27 of 90 answers from 19 of 30 metrosAmerican Heart Association, Joint replacement, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosAmerican Heart Association, Maternity, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosAmerican Heart Association, Pediatrics, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosAmerican Heart Association, Primary care, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosAmerican Heart Association, Psychiatry, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosAmerican Heart Association, Vasectomy, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metros
STS Public Reportingpublicreporting.sts.orgSTS Public Reporting, Brain tumor surgery, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosSTS Public Reporting, Breast cancer, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosSTS Public Reporting, Colonoscopy, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosSTS Public Reporting, Heart surgery, A: 12%, 11 of 90 answers from 7 of 30 metrosSTS Public Reporting, Joint replacement, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosSTS Public Reporting, Maternity, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosSTS Public Reporting, Pediatrics, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosSTS Public Reporting, Primary care, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosSTS Public Reporting, Psychiatry, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosSTS Public Reporting, Vasectomy, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metros
CMScms.govCMS, Brain tumor surgery, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosCMS, Breast cancer, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosCMS, Colonoscopy, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosCMS, Heart surgery, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosCMS, Joint replacement, A: 34%, 31 of 90 answers from 21 of 30 metrosCMS, Maternity, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosCMS, Pediatrics, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosCMS, Primary care, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosCMS, Psychiatry, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosCMS, Vasectomy, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metros
Birdeye reviewsreviews.birdeye.comBirdeye reviews, Brain tumor surgery, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosBirdeye reviews, Breast cancer, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosBirdeye reviews, Colonoscopy, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosBirdeye reviews, Heart surgery, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosBirdeye reviews, Joint replacement, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosBirdeye reviews, Maternity, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosBirdeye reviews, Pediatrics, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosBirdeye reviews, Primary care, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosBirdeye reviews, Psychiatry, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosBirdeye reviews, Vasectomy, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metros
HealthyChildren.orghealthychildren.orgHealthyChildren.org, Brain tumor surgery, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosHealthyChildren.org, Breast cancer, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosHealthyChildren.org, Colonoscopy, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosHealthyChildren.org, Heart surgery, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosHealthyChildren.org, Joint replacement, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosHealthyChildren.org, Maternity, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosHealthyChildren.org, Pediatrics, A: 12%, 11 of 90 answers from 10 of 30 metrosHealthyChildren.org, Primary care, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosHealthyChildren.org, Psychiatry, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosHealthyChildren.org, Vasectomy, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metros
Psychology Todaypsychologytoday.comPsychology Today, Brain tumor surgery, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosPsychology Today, Breast cancer, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosPsychology Today, Colonoscopy, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosPsychology Today, Heart surgery, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosPsychology Today, Joint replacement, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosPsychology Today, Maternity, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosPsychology Today, Pediatrics, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosPsychology Today, Primary care, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosPsychology Today, Psychiatry, A: 8%, 7 of 90 answers from 6 of 30 metrosPsychology Today, Vasectomy, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metros
Planned Parenthoodplannedparenthood.orgPlanned Parenthood, Brain tumor surgery, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosPlanned Parenthood, Breast cancer, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosPlanned Parenthood, Colonoscopy, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosPlanned Parenthood, Heart surgery, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosPlanned Parenthood, Joint replacement, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosPlanned Parenthood, Maternity, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosPlanned Parenthood, Pediatrics, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosPlanned Parenthood, Primary care, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosPlanned Parenthood, Psychiatry, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosPlanned Parenthood, Vasectomy, A: 72%, 65 of 90 answers from 28 of 30 metros
CDCcdc.govCDC, Brain tumor surgery, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosCDC, Breast cancer, A: 1%, 1 of 90 answers from 1 of 30 metrosCDC, Colonoscopy, A: 1%, 1 of 90 answers from 1 of 30 metrosCDC, Heart surgery, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosCDC, Joint replacement, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosCDC, Maternity, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosCDC, Pediatrics, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosCDC, Primary care, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosCDC, Psychiatry, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosCDC, Vasectomy, A: 18%, 16 of 90 answers from 14 of 30 metros
American Urological Assn.auanet.orgAmerican Urological Assn., Brain tumor surgery, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosAmerican Urological Assn., Breast cancer, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosAmerican Urological Assn., Colonoscopy, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosAmerican Urological Assn., Heart surgery, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosAmerican Urological Assn., Joint replacement, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosAmerican Urological Assn., Maternity, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosAmerican Urological Assn., Pediatrics, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosAmerican Urological Assn., Primary care, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosAmerican Urological Assn., Psychiatry, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosAmerican Urological Assn., Vasectomy, A: 4%, 4 of 90 answers from 3 of 30 metros
Breast cancer: percent of 90 answers citing each source, both wordings
Breast cancerAB
HealthgradesHealthgrades, Breast cancer, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosHealthgrades, Breast cancer, B: 6%, 5 of 90 answers from 3 of 30 metros
Mayo ClinicMayo Clinic, Breast cancer, A: 3%, 3 of 90 answers from 1 of 30 metrosMayo Clinic, Breast cancer, B: 1%, 1 of 90 answers from 1 of 30 metros
WebMD doctor directoryWebMD doctor directory, Breast cancer, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosWebMD doctor directory, Breast cancer, B: 3%, 3 of 90 answers from 2 of 30 metros
ThreeBestRatedThreeBestRated, Breast cancer, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosThreeBestRated, Breast cancer, B: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metros
National Cancer InstituteNational Cancer Institute, Breast cancer, A: 57%, 51 of 90 answers from 26 of 30 metrosNational Cancer Institute, Breast cancer, B: 11%, 10 of 90 answers from 8 of 30 metros
NCI cancer center directoryNCI cancer center directory, Breast cancer, A: 12%, 11 of 90 answers from 8 of 30 metrosNCI cancer center directory, Breast cancer, B: 11%, 10 of 90 answers from 5 of 30 metros
American Heart AssociationAmerican Heart Association, Breast cancer, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosAmerican Heart Association, Breast cancer, B: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metros
STS Public ReportingSTS Public Reporting, Breast cancer, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosSTS Public Reporting, Breast cancer, B: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metros
CMSCMS, Breast cancer, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosCMS, Breast cancer, B: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metros
Birdeye reviewsBirdeye reviews, Breast cancer, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosBirdeye reviews, Breast cancer, B: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metros
HealthyChildren.orgHealthyChildren.org, Breast cancer, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosHealthyChildren.org, Breast cancer, B: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metros
Psychology TodayPsychology Today, Breast cancer, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosPsychology Today, Breast cancer, B: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metros
Planned ParenthoodPlanned Parenthood, Breast cancer, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosPlanned Parenthood, Breast cancer, B: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metros
CDCCDC, Breast cancer, A: 1%, 1 of 90 answers from 1 of 30 metrosCDC, Breast cancer, B: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metros
American Urological Assn.American Urological Assn., Breast cancer, A: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metrosAmerican Urological Assn., Breast cancer, B: 0%, 0 of 90 answers from 0 of 30 metros

How to read this. A cell is the share of 90 answers (30 metros, each asked three times) that cited the source anywhere in the answer, rounded: 37 means 33 of 90. This map shows every source cited in at least 10 answers from at least 5 metros in any one service line and wording, with all of its cells, zeros included. Repeats in one metro are not separate markets, so the exact counts below sit beside the number of metros. The two wordings differ in more than one word; a difference between them describes these answers and does not isolate a cause.

Showing Breast cancer

Breast cancer: what the answers cited

The 90 A answers cited 125 different websites and the 90 B answers 107. These are the mapped sources among them.

A, as askedI was just diagnosed with breast cancer. Where should I get treated in [city]?

B, as askedWho is the best breast cancer doctor in [city]?

SourceA, as askedI was just diagnosed with breast cancer. Where should I get treated in [city]?B, as askedWho is the best breast cancer doctor in [city]?Cited pages
National Cancer Institutecancer.gov16 facility profiles, 9 patient education pages, 1 directory list, 1 provider service pageRequest changes from the owner: facility profiles, directory listsReference only: patient education pages, provider service pages
A57%51 of 90 answers · 26 of 30 metros
B11%10 of 90 answers · 8 of 30 metros
NCI cancer center directorycancercenters.cancer.gov7 facility profiles, 2 directory listsRequest changes from the owner
A12%11 of 90 answers · 8 of 30 metros
B11%10 of 90 answers · 5 of 30 metros
Healthgradeshealthgrades.com2 clinician profiles, 1 directory listRequest changes from the owner
A0%0 of 90 answers
B6%5 of 90 answers · 3 of 30 metros
Mayo Clinicmayoclinic.org2 clinician profiles, 1 provider service pagePublished by that provider
A3%3 of 90 answers · 1 of 30 metros
B1%1 of 90 answers · 1 of 30 metros
WebMD doctor directorydoctor.webmd.com2 directory lists, 1 clinician profileRequest changes from the owner
A0%0 of 90 answers
B3%3 of 90 answers · 2 of 30 metros
CDCcdc.gov1 patient education pageReference only
A1%1 of 90 answers · 1 of 30 metros
B0%0 of 90 answers

Other websites cited in at least 5 answers

Below the map’s threshold. A website not listed here was cited in fewer than 5 of 90 answers; every website is in the ranked download.

cancer.orgA9 of 90 · 8 metrosBunder 5
texasoncology.comA7 of 90 · 3 metrosBunder 5
healthcare.utah.eduA6 of 90 · 2 metrosB6 of 90 · 2 metros
cityofhope.orgA5 of 90 · 3 metrosB5 of 90 · 3 metros
flcancer.comA5 of 90 · 2 metrosBunder 5
providence.orgA5 of 90 · 2 metrosBunder 5

Not cited for breast cancer in either wording (0 of 90): ThreeBestRated, American Heart Association, STS Public Reporting, CMS, Birdeye reviews, HealthyChildren.org, Psychology Today, Planned Parenthood, American Urological Assn.

Source guide for both wordings

All 15 sources this comparison maps, counting every page either wording cited.

Listings and records another organization maintains

The owner publishes them, often from data a health system or its clinicians supply, so changes are requested from the owner. Where the owner publishes a way to claim, update or review an entry, the guide links it; where it does not, the guide says so.

Healthgradeshealthgrades.comDirectory lists, Clinician profiles, Facility profiles152answers · 137 pages

Operated by Healthgrades Marketplace, LLC, an RVO Health company.

Directory lists · 74 directory lists cited · request changes from the owner
Maintained by
Healthgrades generates these lists from its own provider profiles; its help center says that data comes from the NPI Registry, patient surveys, government and third-party claims data, and information supplied by professionals or practices.
What a health system can do
The Healthgrades help center says an authorized representative for more than one provider can see a roster of those providers, open each profile for editing, and manage their patient reviews. Owner’s page, checked November 15, 2026.

Healthgrades decides which clinicians a list shows and in what order; claiming changes the profiles behind a list, not the list. 26 of the 74 cited lists carried listings labeled sponsored, which Healthgrades says hospitals and medical groups can buy.

Clinician profiles · 61 clinician profiles cited · request changes from the owner
Maintained by
Healthgrades builds each profile from government and commercial data sources and patient surveys; a clinician or an authorized representative who claims the free profile can edit it, and the help center says Healthgrades does not overwrite information a practice keeps current.
What a health system can do
The Healthgrades for Professionals claim page invites a clinician to find and claim a free profile, asks for a DEA or state license number for verification, and states that only physicians or their authorized representatives may manage a physician's profile. Owner’s page, checked November 15, 2026.

Each cited profile showed a 'Last verified' date and a claim prompt. Healthgrades says profile edits also appear on its partner sites, and that anyone can report incorrect profile information through a form.

Facility profiles · 2 facility profiles cited · request changes from the owner
Maintained by
For the hospital page, Healthgrades computes the ratings itself from Medicare claims, CMS patient survey data and state all-payer data; the group practice page draws on the same provider data, and authorized representatives can edit practice and office locations.
What a health system can do
The help center says an authorized representative for more than one provider can add, edit and remove practices and office locations and choose which providers are associated with each location. Owner’s page, checked November 15, 2026.

The route covers practice and office details only. Healthgrades publishes no route for a hospital to review or correct its hospital ratings.

Not established: Healthgrades publishes no route for a hospital to review or correct its hospital ratings.

National Cancer Institutecancer.govPatient education, Facility profiles, Directory lists, Provider service pages, Other pages76answers · 32 pages

Operated by National Cancer Institute (NCI).

Patient education · 12 patient education pages cited · reference only
Maintained by
NCI; its About This Website page says medical experts, cancer researchers and editors review content before publication, and that PDQ summaries (two of these URLs) are developed and maintained by the PDQ Editorial Boards.
What a health system can do
Reference only.

General reference with no provider listings. The breast cancer diagnosis page alone was cited in 28 answers.

Facility profiles · 16 facility profiles cited · request changes from the owner
Maintained by
NCI hosts the profiles, and 15 of the 16 cited profiles state that the profile information was provided by the cancer center itself; the MD Anderson profile carries no such note.
What a health system can do
Request changes from the owner. The owner publishes no route for this.

A center has a profile once it holds NCI designation. 15 of the 16 cited profiles say the center supplied the text; NCI publishes no process for changing it.

Directory lists · 1 directory list cited · request changes from the owner
Maintained by
NCI.
What a health system can do
Request changes from the owner. The owner publishes no route for this.

Lists only NCI-designated centers; designation comes with NCI's P30 Cancer Center Support Grant.

Provider service pages · 2 provider service pages cited · reference only
Maintained by
NCI and NIH publish these pages about their own clinical programs.
What a health system can do
Reference only.

Pages about NCI's and NIH's own clinical programs.

Other pages · 1 other page cited · reference only
Maintained by
NCI publishes it as budget data.
What a health system can do
Reference only.

A budget record naming grantee institutions, not a provider listing.

Not established: NCI publishes no process for a designated center to update its cancer.gov profile.

WebMD doctor directorydoctor.webmd.comDirectory lists, Clinician profiles, Facility profiles42answers · 37 pages

Operated by WebMD LLC, an Internet Brands company.

Directory lists · 14 directory lists cited · request changes from the owner
Maintained by
WebMD Care generates these lists from its provider profiles, which the profile pages say are sourced from the physicians themselves and publicly available databases.
What a health system can do
The WebMD Care Directories page offers a form to access a free Basic Profile and describes paid Featured Profiles, which it says are pinned to the top of search results for local physicians in the same field. Owner’s page, checked November 15, 2026.

11 of the 14 cited lists showed a 'Featured Results' block, which WebMD describes as paid placement. Claiming changes individual listings, not the order WebMD gives them.

Clinician profiles · 21 clinician profiles cited · request changes from the owner
Maintained by
WebMD Care publishes the profiles; the pages say the data comes from physicians and publicly available databases, that a provider who claims and verifies the profile can update it, and that reviews come from users.
What a health system can do
The profile claim form says registering grants access to update the listing on all sites in WebMD's directory network and that only physicians and practices can update their listings. Owner’s page, checked November 15, 2026.

18 of the 21 cited profiles showed a 'Claim your profile' link; whether the other three are already claimed is not established.

Facility profiles · 2 facility profiles cited · request changes from the owner
Maintained by
WebMD Care compiles the practice page from its provider data; the practice can claim it to update the listing.
What a health system can do
The practice claim form says registering grants access to update the listing on all sites in WebMD's directory network and that only physicians and practices can update their listings. Owner’s page, checked November 15, 2026.

Not established: WebMD's claim forms say only physicians and practices can update listings; we found no route for a health system's central office. Whether three cited clinician profiles without a claim link are already claimed.

CMScms.govQuality records, Other pages31answers · 3 pages

Operated by Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS).

Quality records · 2 quality records cited · request changes from the owner
Maintained by
CMS maintains both program pages; CMS's QualityNet preview page says the hospital data shown on Care Compare is typically submitted by hospitals to meet their quality reporting program requirements, and CMS's About the Data page says clinician performance information comes from the Quality Payment Program and general profile information primarily from PECOS.
What a health system can do
CMS's QualityNet page says each quarter's Care Compare data are made available to participating Inpatient Quality Reporting hospitals for a 30-day preview, about two months before public release, through the Hospital Quality Reporting system. Owner’s page, checked November 15, 2026.

Neither cited page shows a specific hospital or clinician; those records are on Care Compare. The preview is a review period, not a correction procedure. For clinicians and groups, CMS says names, specialty, education and group details are updated through PECOS.

Other pages · 1 other page cited · not established
Maintained by
CMS issued the notice, signed by the acting director of its Division of SF/Seattle Survey & Enforcement; it is a dated, signed PDF rather than a page with update dates.
What a health system can do
Not established.

A federal enforcement notice about one hospital, cited by one joint-replacement answer.

Not established: Whether a hospital can correct Care Compare data after the 30-day preview. Any appeal or correction route for the cited Medicare termination notice.

Psychology Todaypsychologytoday.comDirectory lists, Clinician profiles, Facility profiles29answers · 34 pages

Operated by Sussex Directories Inc..

Directory lists · 14 directory lists cited · request changes from the owner
Maintained by
Psychology Today assembles the list from member profiles; the terms say every listed professional pays a subscription fee and is responsible for keeping its own profile accurate.
What a health system can do
Psychology Today's Join page invites professionals to create a profile that appears in the directory and states a fixed membership fee of $29.95 a month with no contract; it does not describe how to correct an existing profile. Owner’s page, checked November 15, 2026.

A health system's clinicians appear on these lists only if each holds its own paid profile; the terms say every member pays the same fee.

Clinician profiles · 18 clinician profiles cited · request changes from the owner
Maintained by
The listed professional writes and pays for the profile; the terms say profile content is self-reported and/or gathered from verified third-party sources, that each member is responsible for its accuracy, and that Sussex Directories does not control, verify or take responsibility for member content.
What a health system can do
Psychology Today's Join page invites professionals to create a profile that appears in the directory and states a fixed membership fee of $29.95 a month with no contract; it does not describe how to correct an existing profile. Owner’s page, checked November 15, 2026.

The terms make each member responsible for its profile's accuracy and send concerns about a listed professional to Psychology Today's support email.

Facility profiles · 2 facility profiles cited · request changes from the owner
Maintained by
The practice writes and pays for the profile as a Psychology Today member.
What a health system can do
Psychology Today's Join page invites professionals to create a profile that appears in the directory and states a fixed membership fee of $29.95 a month with no contract; it does not describe how to correct an existing profile. Owner’s page, checked November 15, 2026.

These practice-named profiles use the same format as individual clinicians' profiles.

Not established: The site blocked automated loading, so 8 of the 34 cited pages were opened and the rest classified from their addresses. Psychology Today publishes no route for a third party, such as a health system, to correct a clinician's profile beyond a support email and a 'Report an issue' link. How the site's terms, which bar promoting group practices, apply to the two practice-named profiles.

NCI cancer center directorycancercenters.cancer.govFacility profiles, Directory lists23answers · 9 pages

Operated by National Cancer Institute, Office of Cancer Centers.

Facility profiles · 7 facility profiles cited · request changes from the owner
Maintained by
NCI's Office of Cancer Centers publishes a profile for each NCI-designated center and dates each one; these pages do not say who supplies the text.
What a health system can do
Request changes from the owner. The owner publishes no route for this.

A center is listed once it holds NCI designation, which NCI's Office of Cancer Centers says comes with its P30 Cancer Center Support Grant. NCI publishes no process for updating a profile; its contact page lists a phone number and an email address. A profile describes the designated center, which can differ from the hospital or breast program an answer named.

Directory lists · 2 directory lists cited · request changes from the owner
Maintained by
NCI's Office of Cancer Centers compiles both lists of NCI-designated centers.
What a health system can do
Request changes from the owner. The owner publishes no route for this.

Only NCI-designated centers appear, 74 when checked. Designation, which comes with NCI's P30 Cancer Center Support Grant, is what puts a center on the list.

Not established: NCI publishes no process for a designated center to update its directory profile. Who writes these profiles; the cancer.gov profiles for the same centers say the center supplied the text.

STS Public Reportingpublicreporting.sts.orgQuality records22answers · 9 pages

Operated by The Society of Thoracic Surgeons (STS).

Quality records · 9 quality records cited · request changes from the owner
Maintained by
STS calculates and publishes the scores and star ratings from surgical case data that participants (most often a hospital cardiothoracic surgery department or surgical group, occasionally an individual surgeon) submit to the STS National Database.
What a health system can do
STS's FAQ says public reporting is completely voluntary for database participants, who enroll by sending a completed consent form to publicreporting@sts.org and may unenroll at any time. Owner’s page, checked November 15, 2026.

A program appears only if it participates in the STS National Database and consents to publication. STS says results reflect each participant's case mix and are not meant for direct comparison. It publishes no process for disputing a published score.

Not established: STS publishes no process for disputing a published rating.

Birdeye reviewsreviews.birdeye.comDirectory lists, Clinician profiles, Facility profiles21answers · 18 pages

Operated by BirdEye, Inc..

Directory lists · 2 directory lists cited · request changes from the owner
Maintained by
Birdeye generates the list from its own business profiles; the page offers an 'Add business' option for businesses not shown.
What a health system can do
Birdeye's claim page for a cited profile says the business can claim its free profile by email or Google sign-in, confirm its name, email and phone, then add photos, hours, services and links and collect and respond to reviews. Owner’s page, checked November 15, 2026.

Birdeye decides which businesses a list shows and in what order; claiming changes the profiles behind a list.

Clinician profiles · 7 clinician profiles cited · request changes from the owner
Maintained by
Birdeye publishes these profiles before any business involvement; every cited profile stated it had not been claimed by the business owner or representative, and the ratings shown draw on reviews from other sites.
What a health system can do
Birdeye's claim page for a cited profile says the business can claim its free profile by email or Google sign-in, confirm its name, email and phone, then add photos, hours, services and links and collect and respond to reviews. Owner’s page, checked November 15, 2026.

Every cited profile said it had not been claimed. Each has its own claim link and a 'Suggest edits' link.

Facility profiles · 9 facility profiles cited · request changes from the owner
Maintained by
Birdeye publishes these practice profiles before any business involvement; every cited profile stated it had not been claimed, and the ratings shown draw on reviews from other sites.
What a health system can do
Birdeye's claim page for a cited profile says the business can claim its free profile by email or Google sign-in, confirm its name, email and phone, then add photos, hours, services and links and collect and respond to reviews. Owner’s page, checked November 15, 2026.

Every cited profile said it had not been claimed, and 15 of the 16 cited Birdeye profiles showed no reviews written on Birdeye itself; their ratings come from sites such as Facebook, Healthgrades and Yellow Pages.

Not established: Which outside review sites make up each profile's totals.

ThreeBestRatedthreebestrated.comDirectory lists21answers · 15 pages

Operated by Signature Profit LLC.

Directory lists · 15 directory lists cited · request changes from the owner
Maintained by
ThreeBestRated's team selects the three businesses and publishes the entries; its About page says every business is checked manually through a '50-Point Inspection' and that businesses cannot pay to be featured.
What a health system can do
The Update Business page says a listed business can email support@threebestrated.com for small changes or submit a free form for its address, phone, hours, services and other details, which the team reviews manually, taking up to 3 business days, before publishing. Owner’s page, checked November 15, 2026.

Each cited page names exactly three businesses for one specialty and city. A listed business can update its entry; the site decides who is listed.

Pages another provider publishes itself

Only that provider can change them.

Planned Parenthoodplannedparenthood.orgPatient education, Provider service pages77answers · 38 pages

Operated by Planned Parenthood Federation of America, with pages run by its separately incorporated affiliates.

Patient education · 4 patient education pages cited · reference only
Maintained by
PPFA; these pages carry the copyright line "© 2026 Planned Parenthood Federation of America Inc."
What a health system can do
Reference only.

General patient information from Planned Parenthood Federation of America.

Provider service pages · 34 provider service pages cited · published by that provider
Maintained by
The Planned Parenthood affiliate named on each page; affiliate pages carry that affiliate's copyright line, and health center pages say "Operated by" the affiliate.
What a health system can do
Published by that provider.

Health center and affiliate pages, each run by a separately incorporated Planned Parenthood affiliate; only that affiliate can change them. Ten of the 16 cited health center pages did not mention vasectomy when checked.

Mayo Clinicmayoclinic.orgPatient education, Clinician profiles, Provider service pages, Directory lists56answers · 46 pages

Operated by Mayo Clinic (Mayo Foundation for Medical Education and Research).

Patient education · 7 patient education pages cited · reference only
Maintained by
Mayo Clinic editorial staff write these pages and Mayo medical editors review them, according to Mayo's Health Education Policy page; the pages carry a "By Mayo Clinic Staff" byline.
What a health system can do
Reference only.

General articles, but most sit beside Mayo's own 'Doctors and departments' and 'Care at Mayo Clinic' tabs and carry an appointment link, so they lead to Mayo's own service pages.

Clinician profiles · 20 clinician profiles cited · published by that provider
Maintained by
Mayo Clinic publishes these profiles of its own clinicians on its own site.
What a health system can do
Published by that provider.

Profiles of Mayo's own clinicians, most in Phoenix. Only Mayo Clinic can change them.

Provider service pages · 14 provider service pages cited · published by that provider
Maintained by
Mayo Clinic maintains these pages about its own departments, programs and campus buildings.
What a health system can do
Published by that provider.

Mayo's own department, program and campus pages. Only Mayo Clinic can change them.

Directory lists · 5 directory lists cited · published by that provider
Maintained by
Mayo Clinic maintains these lists; four are lists of its own clinicians, and one is a short list of outside primary care providers that Mayo says it selected.
What a health system can do
Published by that provider.

Mayo's own lists of its doctors and departments, plus one page naming three outside primary care organizations Mayo selected, with no way for an outside provider to be added.

General reference

Patient education and clinical guidance with no ordinary way for a health system to add its own information.

American Heart Associationheart.orgPatient education27answers · 7 pages

Operated by American Heart Association.

Patient education · 7 patient education pages cited · reference only
Maintained by
AHA's editorial guidelines say staff writers and editors produce the content, AHA science and medicine advisors review it, and AHA staff publish it.
What a health system can do
Reference only.

None of the cited pages lists, ranks or recognizes a specific hospital or clinician.

CDCcdc.govPatient education23answers · 3 pages

Operated by Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC).

Patient education · 3 patient education pages cited · reference only
Maintained by
CDC; each page names its content source, the Division of Reproductive Health or the Division of Cancer Prevention and Control within the National Center for Chronic Disease Prevention and Health Promotion.
What a health system can do
Reference only.

Reference content with no provider listings. The permanent contraception page, written for clinicians, was cited in 21 answers.

American Urological Assn.auanet.orgPatient education22answers · 5 pages

Operated by American Urological Association (AUA).

Patient education · 5 patient education pages cited · reference only
Maintained by
The AUA; the guideline was written by an AUA expert panel, and the documents carry AUA copyright (the Journal of Urology reprint names American Urological Association Education and Research, Inc.).
What a health system can do
Reference only.

All five cited pages are AUA's 2012 vasectomy guideline for clinicians, one in its journal version. AUA now files it as archived; its 2026 guideline requires a member login.

Not established: Whether AUA's member directory is public; it requires a member login.

HealthyChildren.orghealthychildren.orgDirectory lists, Patient education13answers · 7 pages

Operated by American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP).

Directory lists · 2 directory lists cited · request changes from the owner
Maintained by
The AAP runs the tool, and the page says listing information comes directly from each AAP member's own member profile.
What a health system can do
The page says the Find a Pediatrician feature pulls information directly from an AAP member's profile and that members must update that profile for the information to appear on HealthyChildren.org, with a link to the AAP member account profile page. Owner’s page, checked November 15, 2026.

The route belongs to individual pediatricians: a system's pediatricians who are AAP members update their own AAP profiles, which the tool draws on.

Patient education · 5 patient education pages cited · reference only
Maintained by
The AAP; each article names an AAP source, and the About page says every article is reviewed by AAP pediatricians. The cited symptom checker page is credited to Barton Schmitt MD, FAAP, and copyrighted by Schmitt Pediatric Guidelines LLC.
What a health system can do
Reference only.

General parent information; no cited page is about a specific provider.

Data

Figures

  • Doctor source map · PNG · SVG · PDF
  • Comparison A · “Where should I go?” · PNG · SVG · PDF
  • Comparison B · “Who is the best doctor?” · PNG · SVG · PDF

Methodology & caveats

On , we asked gpt-5.6-luna, the model behind free ChatGPT since August 2026, 3,000 questions about where to get care. We sent them through OpenAI’s developer API, not the ChatGPT app, with web search on and the location set to each metro’s main city. The 30 metros are Census metropolitan areas in three tiers of ten: the ten largest, plus randomly drawn mid-size and small metros. We asked 100 questions in each metro. For 10 service lines, we asked both “where should I go” and “who is the best doctor,” three times each. For 20 more service lines, we asked only “where should I go,” twice. One AI model classified each recommended provider. A second AI model independently classified the providers in 150 answers as a check on the first, and every check passed the minimum we set in advance. Health-system affiliations come from the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality and from system websites, and counts of local doctors from Medicare enrollment data.

Before collecting data, we registered one prediction: in five service lines where patients often choose their own provider, health systems’ share of recommended doctors and practices would be at least 10 percentage points below their share of local doctors. Instead, systems’ share of recommendations came out 9.46 percentage points above their share of local doctors. The 95% uncertainty range for that difference ran from 2.04 to 12.05 points above, entirely above zero, so the prediction failed. We repeated the comparison using only affiliations listed in the agency’s files. Maternity then had no metro with enough confirmed recommendations to compare, so the check covered the other four lines. Across those, systems’ share of recommendations was 5.68 percentage points below their share of local doctors. The uncertainty range ran from 12.42 points below to 0.98 points above, which neither confirms nor rules out the predicted shortfall of at least 10 percentage points. Everything else on this page is descriptive and was not part of that test. The results describe answers from the API on one day in these metros; we did not study the ChatGPT app, rural markets, why an answer recommended a provider, or whether patients booked.

Disclosure. Halcy is a commercial service that sells search and AI-visibility work to healthcare practices, including independent practices. We designed, ran and paid for this study, and we publish the full results so readers can check every figure on this page.